Home » Kalshi moves to block New York restraining order as $36 billion lawsuit returns to state court

Kalshi moves to block New York restraining order as $36 billion lawsuit returns to state court

by Anna Avery
0 comments



Prediction market operator Kalshi has reportedly asked a New York state judge to reject any renewed emergency restraining order issued without hearing its arguments, warning that the proposed restrictions could shut down its exchange nationwide.

Summary

  • Kalshi seeks to prevent New York from securing a restraining order without hearing its defense.
  • A federal judge returned New York’s $36 billion lawsuit against Kalshi to state court.
  • Kalshi cited $178 billion in annualized trading volume when warning of market disruption.
  • Kalshi invoked the CFTC’s August emergency order requiring continued exchange operations.

Sports and gaming attorney Daniel Wallach said on Nov. 20 that Kalshi’s legal representatives at Milbank submitted a late-night letter to Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Melissa Crane, requesting an immediate status conference and an opportunity to respond to any renewed application from New York Attorney General Letitia James.

The filing followed a Nov. 19 ruling by U.S. District Judge Vernon S. Broderick, who granted New York’s request to return its enforcement lawsuit against Kalshi to state court.

Broderick found that the federal court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction over the case. However, he denied the state’s request for attorneys’ fees and costs, finding that Kalshi had presented reasonable grounds for seeking removal.

Kalshi challenges urgency of New York’s restraining order

According to Wallach’s account of the letter, Kalshi argued that James had failed to establish an emergency warranting an ex parte temporary restraining order (TRO), which would allow the court to impose restrictions before the exchange presents its defense.

Milbank pointed to Kalshi’s commercial launch in July 2021 and its introduction of sports event contracts in January 2025, arguing that New York waited several months before commencing enforcement proceedings.

However, Wallach noted that the New York State Gaming Commission had issued a cease-and-desist notice on Oct. 24, 2025, before agreeing to defer enforcement while Kalshi pursued preliminary injunctive relief.

U.S. District Judge Analisa Torres denied that request on July 7, 2026. Kalshi subsequently lost its emergency injunction bid on July 27 while pursuing an appeal.

James filed the $36 billion lawsuit on July 31, but Kalshi transferred the proceedings to federal court that same day. The original restraining order application was subsequently denied as moot, with the attorney general retaining the ability to renew it upon remand, Wallach said.

Kalshi warns proposed restrictions could trigger nationwide market shutdown

Kalshi’s latest objections center on the wording of New York’s original restraining order, which extends beyond sports contracts purchased by customers residing within the state.

The requested restrictions cover contracts relating to “sports, culture, elections, and other events” offered “within or from New York or to persons in New York.”

Since Kalshi maintains its headquarters in New York, Milbank reportedly argued that the geographical scope of the proposed restrictions could prevent the company from serving customers elsewhere in the United States.

Its lawyers questioned whether the undefined reference to other events could encompass contracts covering financial markets, economic indicators and other subjects unrelated to sports wagering.

Wallach said Milbank cited figures from the attorney general’s filings, including Kalshi’s $178 billion annualized trading volume and $22 billion valuation, when explaining the potential consequences of suspending its operations.

The company warned that implementing such an order could force the liquidation of outstanding trading positions and disrupt markets in jurisdictions where its contracts are permitted.

Kalshi reportedly referenced the Third Circuit’s ruling in KalshiEX v. Flaherty, which found that federal commodities legislation preempted the New Jersey gambling restrictions at issue. New Jersey has since sought Supreme Court review of that decision.

Kalshi invokes CFTC emergency order requiring continued operations

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) has previously intervened in the dispute over New York’s proposed restrictions.

As crypto.news previously reported, the regulator exercised its emergency authority on Aug. 11 after receiving notification from Kalshi regarding the potential disruption to derivatives markets.

The commission characterized New York’s enforcement action as a “major market disturbance” and warned that an unexpected shutdown of a federally regulated exchange posed an “existential threat” to market participants and its regulatory jurisdiction.

Under its emergency order, issued pursuant to Section 8a(9) of the Commodity Exchange Act, the agency instructed Kalshi to maintain its exchange operations under federal market requirements.

Milbank reportedly maintains that granting New York’s proposed restraining order would place Kalshi under conflicting state and federal directives, an issue its lawyers want addressed through formal briefing before emergency restrictions are imposed.

New York maintains Kalshi operates an unlicensed gambling business

James has argued that Kalshi’s federal registration does not exempt the company from New York’s gambling regulations, particularly requirements governing licensing, taxation and consumer protection.

The attorney general’s July announcement identified access by customers aged between 18 and 20 as one of the state’s concerns, given New York’s minimum mobile sports betting age of 21.

The lawsuit seeks financial penalties, restitution for consumers and the forfeiture of profits allegedly obtained through unlawful activities.

Wallach said Kalshi contacted the attorney general’s office on Thursday evening to discuss scheduling further proceedings. State representatives indicated they would respond the following day, but Kalshi submitted its letter before receiving that response.



Source link

You may also like

Leave a Comment

About Us

Advertisement

Latest Articles

Editor's Picks

© 2024 Technewsupdate. All rights reserved.